Searching for Genetic Link to Anorexia nervosa
Is there an answer yet?
Introduction:
Anorexia nervosa is an eating disorder that mostly
affects young women.
Patients with Anorexia show excessive restriction on eating,
see themselves as fat when actually underweight
and damage their heart muscles and bones by starvation.
Anorexia is extremely difficult to treat, kills up to 20% of the affected (Roan,
2003).
Another eating disorder often associated with Anorexia is Bulimia nervosa,
which causes affected individuals to go through cycles of binge-eating and compensatory
behaviors,
such as starvation, self-induced vomitting and laxative abuse.
We are surrounded by popular media that glamourizes the Hollywood life style,
and by the ideal body image portrayed on magazine covers and television shows.
So, why do some girls take the subliminal message more seriously than others?
Can there be a genetic cause to a socio-cultural disease, Anorexia nervosa?
I have found that some popular press did a better job than others
at reporting what the scientists have found concerning the above questions.
I have also investigated on how the scientists did the research,
and what the most current biological databases say about the genetic link to
Anorexia.
Popular Press:
Los Angeles Times
Seeking
a genetic link to anorexia nervosa;
U.S. launches study of families with two or more sufferers of the mysterious
and sometimes deadly eating disorder
This article gives a nice account of what Anorexia nervosa is, and emphasizes
that
not just one gene causes this disease, but there may be some common genes that
Anorexia sufferers share. It does not jump to any conclusions, but only mentions
that chromosome 1
seems to be a key player in this disease. I was pleased to note that the article
did not
give speculations for cures or hopeful promises of genetic treatment for Anorexia
nervosa.
CNN
Research
could shed light on eating disorders
This article suggests that eating disorders such as Anorexia and Bulimia
may be caused by an autoimmune disorder, that some proteins that usually help
the body
fight foreign invaders might be attacking normal body processes such as
maintaining body weight. This article claims that a group of scientists studied
57 women
who had eating disorders, and that they found antibodies in their blood
that disrupted their normal food intake. It also suggested that drugs that treat
the regulation of the antibodies might cure Anorexia and Bulimia.
This article helps people understand that a psychiatric disorder such as Anorexia
could have a significant biological cause in addition to strenuous environmental
factors.
However, the conversation shown in this article seems to oversimplify the disease,
and might mislead the readers to think that the cure for Anorexia is in near
future.
Scientific Publication:
American Journal of Human Genetics
Evidence
for a susceptibility gene for Anorexia Nervosa on Chromosome 1
Dr. Grice and his colleagues first investigated 192 families who included
at least one case of Anorexia or Bulimia nervosa, but found only a weak linkage
on chromosome 4.
However, when they narrowed the genomewide search to the subset of 37 families
who included at least two cases of strictly Anorexic patients without the self-vomitting
symptoms of Bulimia,
they found a statistically significant location on chromosome 1p that might
indicate
individuals who are susceptible to Anorexia nervosa (Grice et al., 2002).
Human Molecular Genetics
Linkage analysis
of anorexia nervosa incorporating behavioral covariates
Dr. Devlin and his colleagues explored linkage between behavioral traits
and gene loci.
They had two behavioral covariates that accompanied the individuals diagnosed
with Anorexia:
drive-for-thinness and obsessionality. They studied 196 families that included
affected sibling
or relative pairs, and searched the genome with 387 short tandem repeat markers.
They found three different loci that gave statistically significant results:
one on chromosome 1,
another on chromosome 2, and the last on chromoseom 13 (Devlin et al. 2002).
National Center for Biotechnology Information
(NCBI)
says that
the official gene symbol and name have not yet been determined,
and the interim name used for this locus is ANON: susceptibility to Anorexia
nervosa.
The locus ID used in NCBI is 171514,
and the marker used
to identify this region of chromosome 1 is called D1S3721.
The working draft nucleic acid sequence information can be found here.
No functional protein for this gene could yet be found on PDB.
Gene Map
locus: Susceptibility to Anorexia Nervosa
Online Mendelian
Inheritance in Man: Information on AN gene
Figure 1. Illustration of chromosome 1 and the location of susceptibility to
Anorexia Nervosa gene.
Image taken from NCBI
human map viewer.
Is there an answer yet?
Considering the fact that the researchers do not even have an official
name
for the "Anorexia" gene on chomosome 1, I know that more news will
follow from current research.
LA Times has been cautious in announcing what the researchers have found so
far,
but CNN seems to have oversimplified the complexity involved in eating disorders.
But the idea that genetic factors could play significant roles in a socio-cultural
disorder
is definitely worth the investigation, and will provide footsteps to more effective
treatment in the future.
References:
Devlin, B.; Bacanu, S.-A.; Klump, K. L.; Bulik, C. M.; Fichter, M. M.; Halmi,
K. A.; Kaplan, A. S.; Strober, M.; Treasure, J.; Woodside, D. B.; Berrettini,
W. H.; Kaye, W. H. :
Linkage analysis of anorexia nervosa incorporating behavioral covariates. Hum.
Molec. Genet. 11: 689-696, 2002.
Grice, D. E.; Halmi, K. A.; Fichter, M. M.; Strober, M.; Woodside, D. B.; Treasure,
J. T.; Kaplan, A. S.; Magistretti, P. J.; Goldman, D.; Bulik, C. M.; Kaye, W.
H.; Berrettini, W. H. :
Evidence for a susceptibility gene for anorexia nervosa on chromosome 1. Am.
J. Hum. Genet. 70: 787-792, 2002.
Roan, S.: Seeking a genetic link to anorexia nervosa;
U.S. launches study of families with two or more sufferers of the mysterious
and sometimes deadly eating disorder. Los Angeles Times: April 7, 2003. LexisNexis
Academic Link to this article
"Research could shed light on eating disorders". CNN health. 10 December
2002.
http://www.cnn.com/2002/HEALTH/conditions/12/10/otsc.anorexia.antibodies/index.html
This web page was produced as an assignment for
an undergraduate course at Davidson College.